Opening Statements in Sanity Phase of O'Rourke Trial Begin

Regarding the shooting at Kelly Elementary, O'Rourke believed his former employer AIG "made him do it."

A man was legally insane when he opened fire on the playground of a Carlsbad elementary school in a rampage that left two second- graders wounded, his attorney said today, but a prosecutor said the defendant gave police conflicting statements on why he committed the "terrorist act."

In his opening statement in the sanity trial of Brendan O'Rourke, Deputy Public Defender Dan Segura told jurors that delusions and a mental disease led the defendant to believe that his former employer, AIG Inc., and Illinois politicians were involved in a conspiracy to get back at him. "You have a diseased mind, your thinking isn't always right," Segura told the jury.

O'Rourke, 42, was of seven counts each of premeditated attempted murder and assault with a firearm for the Oct. 8, 2010, attack at .

The defense now has the burden to prove that O'Rourke was insane at the time of the shooting. If the defendant is found sane, he faces 103 years to life in state prison. If the jury finds him insane, he could be sent to a state mental hospital.

Four psychiatrists will testify that O'Rourke suffered from schizophrenia or a delusion disorder, or a combination of both, when he opened fire on the school grounds, Segura said. Among O'Rourke's mental illnesses is a "persecutory delusion" that someone is out to get him, his attorney said. The disease makes people "not in touch with reality" and "believing things that simply weren't true," Segura told the jury.

While he worked for the AIG insurance company in Illinois, O'Rourke witnessed someone using cocaine at a party, and because of that, he developed the thought that he was part of a conspiracy and that someone was out to get him, Segura said. Also, his boss told O'Rourke to stop saying someone was accusing him of sexual harassment, and the defendant decided to move from Illinois to California to "get away," the defense attorney said, adding that his client's roommate also mentally tortured him by telling him he couldn't escape the conspiracy.

Regarding the shooting at Kelly Elementary, O'Rourke believed AIG "made him do it," according to Segura. But Deputy District Attorney Summer Stephan said O'Rourke gave police conflicting statements on why he carried out the attack at the school. In one interview right after the shooting, O'Rourke said AIG supplied him with a propane tank that he brought to the scene. Asked three days later where he got the propane tank, the defendant told police he bought it months earlier, the prosecutor said.

O'Rourke initially said he didn't shoot at children but shot at the propane tank, which was left by a fence he climbed, Stephan said. When the defendant's computer was examined, it was determined that he looked at a website concerning safety with propane tanks, the prosecutor said. While he worked for AIG in 2001, O'Rourke became obsessed with a woman and was accused of sexually harassing another woman, Stephan said. When the granddaughter of his apartment manager told O'Rourke she wasn't interested in going on a date, he went to police with a tank top he had stolen from her room to try to prove they were a couple, Stephan said.

In 2010, months before the school shooting, O'Rourke showed up near a woman's apartment in Oceanside, and when she complained to the manager, the defendant was given a 60-day eviction notice, Stephan said. O'Rourke's anger grew in emails to his brother, and he told his sibling that he was joining AIG so he could "ruin people's lives," the prosecutor said. Stephan suggested O'Rourke "lashed out" because he wasn't able to date "20-something" women, as he desired.

In her closing argument in the trial's guilt phase, Stephan told jurors that the defendant climbed a fence at the school around noon and fired six shots at children, wounding two girls who suffered arm wounds. O'Rourke's crime spree certainly would have been much worse had it not been for school staff members who confronted him and the fact that his .357- Magnum revolver jammed and he was unable to re-load, authorities said.

–City News Service

Like this article? Like us on Facebook , too. Or follow us on Twitter .

And be sure to stay in the local loop by subscribing to our newsletter
—every morning we’ll deliver Carlsbad news, announcements, blogs and
calendar events right to your inbox.

Deanne Goodman March 06, 2012 at 10:31 PM
I don't want him to get any less of a max sentence, BUT I don't see how anyone who commits a crime like this isn't insane. He definitely sounds like he has mental illness that unfortunately was not properly treated. Just my opinion, feel free to comment and share yours.
Sam Smith March 07, 2012 at 12:34 AM
Insanity by itself is not the same as motive. How does the school tie into his delusions? This case has too many unanswered questions.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »